, Decision_act (EU) 1999/508

In forcesince 14 Oct 1998

Under the privatisation procedure followed, which is considered to be impartial and transparent, the only firm offer for the acquisition of SMC was that made by Banque Chaix, which offered FRF 10 million. The recovery plan, to be paid for by the buyer, will cost Banque Chaix a total of some FRF 950 million, equal to the accumulated losses forecast for the three years 1998, 1999 and 2000: in order to comply with the regulatory solvency ratios it will have to offset these losses by recapitalising the company.

The total cost to be borne by the buyer includes the cost of implementing the redundancy programme, which has been estimated at around FRF [...](18) million. Even allowing for the possibility that the buyer might invoke the State guarantee of FRF 423 million for any unidentified risks, the price paid is a positive price, and exceeds the value estimated by the consultant.

The Commission concludes that the selling price agreed by the parties is a market price and does not involve aid to the buyer.

5.3. The compatibility of the aid granted

In considering the compatibility of the aid the Commission will be following the general principles set out in the Community Guidelines on State aid for rescuing and restructuring firms in difficulty(19), which clarify the tests which must be satisfied if aid of this kind is to be considered compatible with the Treaty. The measures at issue here are not "rescue" measures within the meaning of the Guidelines, because they are not temporary measures taken pending a restructuring operation, so that it remains to be considered whether they constitute restructuring aid, and if so whether they satisfy the tests for the compatibility of restructuring aid.

The Commission believes that restructuring aid can "facilitate the development of certain economic activities" and "does not adversely affect trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest" where the following conditions are met.

1.

There must be full implementation of a restructuring plan which within a reasonable time restores the requisite minimum return on capital invested, and thus ensures the long-term viability of the business.

2.

There must be a quid pro quo sufficient to offset the distortive effect of the aid on competition, so that it can be concluded that the aid is not contrary to the common interest.