, Decision_act (EU) 1999/508

In forcesince 14 Oct 1998

Accordingly, a private investor would not have carried out such recapitalisation or given such a guarantee; and as the measures are liable to affect trade between Member States, they do contain elements of State aid within the meaning of Article 92(1). As the Commission made clear at the outset of the proceedings, the measures may be held to be compatible with the common market only under Article 92(3)(c), on the basis of the new restructuring plan put forward by the buyer, which must in particular show that the company can become viable.

5.2.3. The possibility that the selling price might involve aid to the buyer

When it extended the proceedings on 14 July 1998, the Commission said it would have to check whether, in the light of the privatisation procedure pursued, the selling price might involve aid to the buyer.

At recital 5.2.1, the Commission concluded that the privatisation procedure ensured that SMC's shares were transferred with the necessary impartiality and transparency.

The bank acting as consultant to the Treasury has estimated the value of the company; if the buyer, Banque Chaix, bought the shares at a price below their value, there would be a presumption that it had received State aid.

The value of SMC as estimated by the Treasury's consultant bank, after recapitalisation by the State and before deduction of the costs of any redundancy programme, varies between FRF 50 million and FRF 250 million. The consultant bank used several methods ordinarily applied in the valuation of businesses, based on revalued net assets, current stock exchange value, and current transaction value of the own funds. The consultant bank's valuation clearly specifies that it takes no account of restructuring costs deriving from a reduction in staff: it has been estimated that a restructuring plan costing between FRF [...](16) million and FRF [...](17) million is needed, which would have to be paid for by the buyer.

On the basis of this valuation, and once the restructuring costs deriving from a reduction in staff are taken into account, the value of the bank is negative.