, Decision_act (EU) 1999/508

In forcesince 14 Oct 1998

The successive capital injections in 1994, 1995 and 1997 became necessary for SMC's survival because the comprehensive restructuring measures applied since 1993 failed to achieve some of their objectives and were not sufficient to restore the bank to viability. Under the plan, the bank ought to have made a loss of about FRF 190 million in 1993 and become profitable from 1994 onward. In fact the loss in 1993 turned out worse than forecast, at about FRF 317 million, and 1994 ended in a loss of FRF 1257 million. SMC had to turn to its shareholder in order to comply with the minimum solvency ratio of 8 %. The same thing happened in 1995. Given the worsening in the bank's financial situation in 1997, the State decided to launch the procedure for the sale of SMC, because it had concluded that the only possible way to ensure that the bank had any future was to associate it with a solid partner with the know-how needed to complete its restructuring. At the same time the State would recapitalise the company for the last time in order to cover losses made and risks incurred by the bank in the past.

Without the injection of State capital the bank would have been obliged to seek bankruptcy proceedings. SMC is being sold to a private buyer, who undertakes to restructure it; the price to be paid is FRF 10 million, so that the State has not recovered its investment nor obtained a return in proportion to the risk of the operation. The State has not acted as a private investor in a market economy would have done, and the measures it has taken to assist SMC must be considered State aid.

Turning now to the scale of the aid, it must be borne in mind that all the increases in capital were intended to cover losses. The State financing was therefore almost entirely non-refundable. It must be concluded that the State aid component in the capital injections is equal to the whole sum of FRF 5868 million.

The Commission has also to evaluate the aid component in the guarantee of FRF 423 million given by the State. The State here undertakes to indemnify the buyer for any injury caused by a liability whose origin was not revealed to it, or by a tax liability which is precisely identified but uncertain. Whether or not this guarantee will be invoked is not clear, because essentially it covers risks which are not identified and hypothetical events internal to SMC.