The French authorities have cited the first paragraph of Article 52 of the French Banking Law; the Commission does not contest the validity of this provision in the light of the European Banking Directives. But it would point out that under this rule shareholders are to be asked to support a credit institution that finds itself in difficulty, but they are not required to do so. Neither the French authorities nor the other interested parties have referred to any obligation on the part of shareholders to provide support. In some French bank failures the shareholders have been asked to support the bank by the Governor of the Banque de France, and have refused; and in the recent Compagnie du BTP case the Paris Court of Appeal confirmed that Article 52 of the Banking Law was not be interpreted as binding on the shareholders(13). Where the main shareholders in banks have indeed provided support, they have done so either to safeguard their interests as owners of other businesses or to avoid graver legal consequences. This cannot be taken to mean that a shareholder in a bank is always and everywhere under a general obligation to meet the bank's liabilities. Such an obligation would de facto run counter to the principle that the liability of the shareholders is to be borne by them in proportion to the capital they have contributed to the company. And if such an obligation existed it would constitute discrimination between privately- and publicly-owned banks, because a private investor does not have access to the same unlimited resources as the State. In practice, it would make it impossible for a private shareholder to have majority control of a privately-owned bank of any size, because of the colossal sums it might be called on to find, and would thus further discriminate between privately- and publicly-owned banks.
, Decision_act (EU) 1999/508
In forcesince 14 Oct 1998