, Decision_act (EU) 1999/508

In forcesince 14 Oct 1998

In the course of the proceedings, the Commission has been shown observations made by the Commission Bancaire in a letter of 27 December 1994 to the chairman of SMC's board of directors: the Commission gathers from these observations that the 1993 recovery plan did not follow the recommendations of the Commission Bancaire, which had drawn attention to weaknesses in the bank's system of risk assessment. The Commission Bancaire emphasises that the development of new activities such as market operations and property financing and of specialised subsidiaries has not always been accompanied by the introduction of measurement and monitoring machinery, with the result that management and directors have sometimes not been aware or have had only an incomplete picture of the risks being taken. The Commission Bancaire indicates that some of these weaknesses had already been pointed out in an earlier report in 1992, and nevertheless still existed in 1994. The Commission Bancaire takes the view that in 1993 and 1994 no progress was made with supervision of assistance to property developers or of market operations, or with headquarters control over the network of branches and subsidiaries.

Thus, SMC's negative results derive in part from factors internal to the bank which were foreseeable but which apparently were not taken into account when the 1993 restructuring plan was drawn up. These factors were not brought to the Commission's attention when it assessed the first capital injection, for 1993, which amounted to FRF 860 million.

The Commission now takes the view, therefore, that the injection of capital by the State in respect of the year 1993 does constitute aid caught by Article 92: the State, as the shareholder, ought to have been aware that the capital injection would not produce a normal return; and indeed rather than being able to anticipate an appropriate return on its investment, without having to provide further financing, the State actually had to inject additional capital which amounted to even more than what had been decided in 1993.