, Decision_act (EU) 1998/365

In forcesince 1 Oct 1997

On 5 January 1994, the Paris Commercial Court, on the basis of Article 177 of the Treaty, put eight questions relating to the interpretation of Articles 92 and 93 of the Treaty to the Court of Justice. The Commission presented its comments on the matter on 6 May 1994. The French Government, which intervened in May 1994, attached to its comments a study by the firm Ernst & Young, in response to the two Braxton studies.

In February 1996 the Commission opened the procedure provided for under Article 93(2) of the Treaty, in respect inter alia of the assistance provided by the Post Office to SFMI-Chronopost over the period 1986 to 1991(2). The Commission considered that the possibility that State aid had been granted to SFMI-Chronopost by France (directly or through the intermediary of the Post Office) could not be ruled out.

In particular, as regards the assistance by the Post Office to SFMI-Chronopost, the information available suggests that only in 1992 did the prices charged by the postal administration match actual costs plus a profit margin. The Commission did not have sufficient information to rule out the possibility that, during the financial years before and after 1992, SFMI-Chronopost had benefited from State aid.

The Commission did not have sufficiently detailed information to allow it to dismiss the possibility that the establishment of SFMI-Chronopost had involved a transfer of resources from the State in some form or other.

No information was available as to how far there had been observance of one of the conditions to which the participants in the joint venture GDEW had subscribed when the concentration had been authorised. That condition was that, unless it was shown that no cross subsidies had been paid, the parties undertook to offer to competitors the same services as those provided for the joint venture, in accordance with the principle of equal treatment for equivalent transactions, so as to exclude the risk of a transfer of public resources to one of the players on the express delivery market. The same considerations apply to admittance to the postal infrastructures to operators other than the joint venture, as from 1 January 1995.