No State aid arises if the internal rate of return ('IRR`) of the investment exceeds the cost of capital of the company (that is to say, the normal rate of return that a private investor would require under similar circumstances). To work out the IRR the Commission has taken into account, on the one hand the equity injection by the Post Office in 1986, and on the other hand the dividends distributed by SFMI-Chronopost over the period 1986 to 1991, and the value of that company in 1991. The Commission following standard investment appraisal techniques, has calculated SFMI-Chronopost's value in 1991 by inflating the cashflow generated by that company in that year, using a multiplier coefficient. That multiplier coefficient is a function of both the average growth rate (10 %, which was the expected growth rate of the delivery express market in France at the end of 1991) of the cashflow and the discounting rate used (13,91 %). The latter is the cost of equity (10). The formula used is,
>NUM>C/
>DEN>r-g
where
C is the cashflow in 1991,
r is the cost of equity,
g is the growth rate.
The Commission has, on this basis, valued SFMI-Chronopost at FRF 564 million at the end of 1991. The reliability of this figure is confirmed by the price of FRF 180,4 million paid by GDEW in June 1992 for the acquisition of the international business of SFMI-Chronopost, which accounted for approximately one-third of the total business (FRF 180,4 × 3 = FRF 541,2 million).
The analysis carried out by the Commission covers the period 1986 to 1991 (before SFMI was transferred to GDNEW). This is the start-up period when, according to the complainant, SFMI-Chronopost received the largest amount of State aid.
The Commission has worked out the IRR and compared it with SFMI-Chronopost's cost of equity in 1986 (13,65 %) (11) the year when the company was incorporated and started its operations. This has permitted it to verify whether the profitability of the whole capital venture has been adequate. The IRR calculated by the Commission is largely in excess of the cost of equity in 1986. Therefore no State aid was involved in the financial transactions between the Post Office and its subsidiary over the years 1986 to 1991. This conclusion is all the more valid for the years subsequent to 1991, when the amount of dividends paid out was higher than in the previous period.