The Commission considers that internal prices at which products and services are transacted between companies belonging to the same group do not involve any financial advantage whatsoever if they are full-cost prices (total costs plus a mark-up to remunerate equity capital investment). In this case payments made by SFMI-Chronopost did not cover total costs over the first two years of operation, but covered total costs before central and local offices' overheads. The Commission considers that this situation is not abnormal since revenues from the operations of a new firm belonging to a group of companies may cover only variable costs in the start-up period. Once the undertaking has stabilised its position on the market, the revenues generated by it must be in excess of variable costs so as to make a contribution to the fixed costs of the group. Over the first two years (1986 to 1987) of operation payment made by SFMI-Chronopost covered not only variable costs, but also some fixed costs (such as buildings and vehicles). France has shown that as from 1988 the remuneration paid by SFMI-Chronopost for the assistance covers all the costs incurred by the Post Office, plus a contribution by way of interest on its equity capital. Therefore, the logistical and commercial assistance was provided by the Post Office to its subsidiary under normal business conditions and did not constitute State aid.
The Commission has also considered whether the Post Office behaviour as a shareholder of SFMI-Chronopost was commercially justified under the market economy investor principle. Under that test, to establish whether a transaction between a Member State and an undertaking contains State aid, it is necessary to verify whether the undertaking would have been able to obtain the monies on the private capital markets. To assess whether the Post Office has behaved like a market economy investor the Commission has to look at the return to the parent company in terms of dividends distributed and capital growth.