France has demonstrated that in 1993 (namely before the introduction of the normal tax rate) the Post Office was in a disadvantageous position compared to the companies subject to the common tax system. The Post Office paid FRF 78 million by way of payroll tax, and the non-refundable VAT was FRF 274 million. The Post Office's turnover in the dispatches sector was FRF 5,465 billion in 1993. Of the corresponding customers 16,6 % were not subject to VAT and 83,4 % were subject to VAT. It follows from the calculation carried out by the French authorities that the Post Office enjoyed a theoretical advantage in respect of the customers not subject to VAT (the advantage is theoretical because this is a segment of the dispatching market which is not operated by the competitors). On the other hand, the Post Office suffered from a FRF 278 million disadvantage in respect of the customers which are subject to VAT. The global net disadvantage stemming from the exemption from VAT and the payment of payroll tax is at least FRF 174,6 million. 1993 was a typical year in terms of volume of activity and expenses of the Post Office and the conclusions drawn for that year are valid for the other years prior to 1994. Therefore, as regards stamp duty the Post Office did not profit from any particular tax benefit which might have been transferred to SFMI-Chronopost.
As regards the periods allowed for payment, the Commission is satisfied with the information provided by France, which clearly show the absence of any kind of advantage for SFMI-Chronopost.
As regards the utilisation of the Post Office's vehicles as advertising media, the Commission considers that this forms part of the commercial assistance provided by the Post Office to SFMI-Chronopost. The considerations set out above for the commercial assistance are also valid in this respect.
As regards Radio France's advertising, the Commission has no evidence that SFMI-Chronopost paid a price below the market price for the advertising of Skypack. It is clear from the information provided by France that SFMI-Chronopost enjoyed no preferential treatment.
As for the dispatching platforms, France has stated that SFMI-Chronopost's dispatches do not transit on them. Therefore, SFMI-Chronopost does not benefit from any advantage in relation to that investment.