, Decision_act (EU) 1998/365

In forcesince 1 Oct 1997

As regards the conditions subscribed by the Post Office within the framework of the authorisation of the GDEW joint venture, the Commission has been able to prove that no State aid has been granted to SFMI-Chronopost. Moreover, France has informed the Commission that the Post Office had received no application to gain access to its network. This is acknowledged by SFEI, which admits to being unaware of any such application lodged with the Post Office. SFEI's member undertakings are integrated firms, which are not interested in access to the Post Office's network.

As regards the alleged tax exemptions, by way of a preliminary remark the Commission points out that SFMI-Chronopost is a normal company which is subject to the same tax system as its private competitors. The Commission has verified in this case whether SFMI-Chronopost benefits from any direct or indirect advantage in relation to stamp duty and payroll tax. In respect of stamp duty, France has informed the Commission that SFMI-Chronopost's dispatches are subject to this tax irrespective of whether they are transported by the Post Office or not. Consequently, as far as this tax is concerned SFMI-Chronopost enjoys no special treatment or financial advantage over its competitors.

As regards the payroll tax, the complainant's claim about the Post Office being exempted from this tax until October 1994 is unfounded. Before that date the Post Office was subject to a reduced tax rate of 4,25 %. The tax charge borne by the Post Office ranged from FRF 1,049 billion in 1986 to FRF 1,136 billion in 1990. The ordinary tax rate of 9,25 % has been in force since October 1994. However, the tax treatment of the Post Office in the dispatching sector (including express courier) has always been in this respect less favourable than the common tax system. The Post Office is exempted from VAT under Article 13 A of the Sixth VAT Directive. Hence the Post Office pays VAT on its purchases but is unable to deduct or apply for reimbursement of the tax paid out. On the other hand, the Post Office, unlike the ordinary companies which are subject to VAT, is subject to a payroll tax, which is an alternative to VAT. As a result the tax charge borne by the Post Office is heavier than that of ordinary companies irrespective of the reduced rate of payroll tax.