Recital 180, Decision_act (EU) 1994/210

In forcesince 29 Mar 1994

The 'note to board members' concerning item 6 on the agenda for the meeting of Intercontainer's Management Board of 30 November 1989 has the following to say on the same subject:

'Point 2.1

The obstacle which the railways are coming up against in traffic from and to the western ports is not the (intense) competition from other modes of transport but an objective, internal conflict: although SNCB, NS and DB wish to develop traffic from and to the western ports, DB is seeking above all not to jeopardize its relations and links with the northern ports.'

'Point 2.3

Tariff structure

The tariff basis applied to multi-port supply was established in accordance with the tariff structure of the "InGrid" model. Thanks to competitive prices, InGrid was able, in traffic with the German seaports, to achieve considerable success on the market. When the InGrid structure was "transposed" to the western ports within the framework of MCN, account was taken not so much of market prices on the western route as of tariff protection measures for traffic to and from the northern ports.

There are, therefore, within "multi-port supply", two tariff structures: a competitive and flexible price system applied to northern port traffic on the one hand and, on the other hand, on the western routes, a structure not in keeping with the competitive situation and extremely difficult to change.'

'Point 3.1

MCN was launched at a joint press conference in Aachen. The public statement augured well for the future, although it was made clear that MCN supply would certainly have to be further developed and improved in the light of the market's reaction.

After this long incubation period, customer interest was manifest; on the other hand, the prices and services on offer did not exactly arouse wild enthusiasm. The measures taken with the political aim of protecting northern port traffic meant that MCN was able only in a few exceptional instances to propose competitive prices on the western routes.

No sooner had MCN been created than DB introduced, within the framework of the "KLV-Neu", a new tariff structure for carriage from and to the northern ports, offering in some cases, considerable price reductions. The difference between the equal price limits imposed on some and the unequal price reductions granted to others soon undermined the credibility of the supply of rail services from and to the western ports.'