, Decision_act (EU) 1992/11

In forcesince 31 Jul 1991

The Commission can see no valid argument for attempting at this late stage to substitute a 'representative range of prices' for the single price which emerged from the District Valuer's report, in the absence of any earlier proposal to this effect or of any reasonable criteria for delimiting such a range. To attempt to introduce a range of values at this stage would only introduce an element of unwarranted arbitration and uncertainty and would run counter to the pursuit of fairness and objectivity which has been the Commission's goal in this whole procedure. The Commission would point out in this context that the valuation report commissioned independently by the United Kingdom authorities itself concluded with a precise single figure valuation and made no reference to a range within which a 'fair commercial value' may be.

Finally, the Commission has examined the confidential evidence produced by Toyota on alternative site offers, together with the evidence on industrial and warehouse land values from the Valuation Office forwarded by the United Kingdom authorities and has found that it does not detract from the conclusion that the transaction between the DCC and Toyota contained State aid of £ 4,2 million.

In these circumstances, the Commission concludes that the difference of £ 4,2 million between the District Valuer's valuation of the site of £ 22,5 million and the price paid by Toyota of £ 18,3 million represents State aid by the DCC to the company.

There is considerable intra-Community trade in passenger motor vehicles; amounting to 6 398 000 units in 1990, equivalent to ECU 48,292 million. the aid of £ 4,2 million granted by the DCC to Toyota will, therefore, affect intra-Community trade in cars and therefore threatens to distort competition in this market. Consequently, it constitutes State aid in favour of Toyota within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty.

VI

This aid, which falls outside the scope of any approved scheme, should have been notified to the Commission as provided for by Article 93 (3) of the EEC Treaty. Moreover, the particular commercial activity involved comes within the parameters of the Community framework on State aid to the motor vehicle industry (2). This provides that 'As regards aid to be granted outside the scope of an approved aid scheme, any such project, whatever its cost and aid intensity, is of course subject without exception to the obligation of notification pursuant to Article 93 (3) of the EEC Treaty.'