, Decision_act (EU) 1992/11

In forcesince 31 Jul 1991

At a further meeting on 20 June, also attended by representatives of Toyota, certain documents were handed over to the Commission; others were referred to and formally submitted by letter later the same day by Toyota's legal representatives. These latter documents included:

–

the speaking note of the principal Toyota representative,

–

a comparison of land costs in South Wales, Burnaston and Humberside,

–

a wider comparison of prices of undeveloped industrial land examined by Toyota.

The other documents handed over by the United Kingdom representatives included:

–

a copy of a letter dated 3 June 1991 from the District Valuer in response to a request from the Department of Trade and Industry to consider the effect choosing April 1989 as opposed to February 1990 as a valuation date might have had on this report. This letter stated that market conditions had in fact deteriorated over that period and stated the Valuer's 'firm conclusion that the value in April 1989 would not have been less than that which I reported at February 1990. In fact I would put the value the same at both dates.',

–

copies of two reports dated 13 and 14 June 1991 made by a United Kingdom private property consultancy firm, following a request of 7 June by the DTI, acting on its own initiative; the first analysed the changes in land values during the period April 1989 to February 1990 in the Derby area and the second provided an alternative valuation of the 580 acres as of February 1990. The latter report, which draws in part on information provided for by DTI, valued the site at £ 19 million. The other study concluded that, excluding the Toyota effect, the growth in land values over the 10-month period would have been 18 %,

–

tables of the range of industrial and warehouse land values as of 1 April 1989 and 1990 drawn from the Property Market Report by the Valuation Office.

During the meeting the United Kingdom representatives argued that land prices in general increased significantly between April 1989 and February 1990. Moreover, as land valuation is inevitably arbitrary and contains a subjective element, the parties should be more concerned with establishing a reasonable price range rather than a single absolute figure, particularly as the District Valuer himself had acknowledged that he had little or no point of reference for his valuation.