, Decision_act (EU) 1992/11

In forcesince 31 Jul 1991

The Commission cannot accept that the break-even approach by the DCC to the package which it offered to Toyota, as evidenced by the minutes of the Policy Committee of the DCC of 21 November 1989 cited above and confirmed in subsequent correspondance with the United Kingdom authorities, corresponded to the behaviour of a commercial vendor. This approach was based explicitly on the estimated cost of assembling the land and of providing access and services to the site. The 'significant planning and other constraints' which, according to the DCC, characterized the site and influenced its market price did not apply to the purchasers, Toyota. The Commission cannot accept the proposition that a rough estimate of the cost of assembling mainly agricultural land and providing services to it as a valid substitute for the market price or the best that the DCC could have reasonably obtained, as it bore no relation to industrial land values (3).

In these circumstances, and given its acceptance that the site sale should be viewed as one single transaction, the Commission saw no alternative to having the total site valued with the same terms of reference as the original valuation carried out on the 280-acre element and comparing the resulting valuation with the price paid by Toyota in order to establish if the transaction entailed State aid. The United Kingdom authorities accepted this approach in March 1991 and did not query or object to the proposed terms of reference for the valuation or the suggestion that it be carried out by the District Valuer.