, Decision_act (EU) 1992/11

In forcesince 31 Jul 1991

Toyota Motor Corporation is the largest motor-vehicle producer based in Japan. In 1990 total group sales worldwide amounted to 4,4 million units, and group net sales were valued at ECU 58,084 million. Imports of Toyota vehicles into the Community in the same year amounted to 351 000 units, representing 2,7 % of Community car registrations. The investment by the company in the Burnaston plant announced in 1989 continued a series of ventures designed to strengthen the company's ties with Europe. Toyota is, in its own words, 'committed to becoming a fully-accepted member of the European automobile industry'.

The passenger car market in Western Europe underwent a period of rapid growth in the late 1980s but the market, with the sole exception of Germany, has declined sharply in recent times and the short-term outlook remains difficult and uncertain. In the medium to long term, it would appear reasonable at this point to assume a return to an underlying annual growth rate of the order of 1 to 2 %.

V

In initiating the present procedure, the Commission stated that 'The question of the existence or not of State aid centres on whether the terms and conditions of sale of the site to Toyota by the DCC depart from normal commercial practice and criteria to such an extent as to constitute State aid in favour of Toyota within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the EEC Treaty'. This remains the point of departure for consideration of the case. The Commission fully accepts that the United Kingdom Government did not itself intend that aid should be given to the project. The Commission has also accepted from the outset that there is no evidence to suggest that Toyota requested State aid or intended benefiting directly or indirectly from State aid through the terms of transfer of the site. However, this absence of intention on the part of Toyota does not mean that no State aid was entailed in the sale of the site by the DCC. It is also clear that the amount of aid involved is small in relation to the overall cost of the project and that Toyota would have gone ahead with the project in any event without the aid.