, Decision_act (EU) 1992/11

In forcesince 31 Jul 1991

The DCC was obliged by domestic statute to sell the site to Toyota for the best consideration that could reasonably be obtained. In practice, according to the United Kingdom authorities, this should account for factors such as the nature and location of the land, planning and other development constraints and the market for land. This perspective is consistent with the Commission's point of view, that the behaviour of a public authority in disposing of an asset to a commercial interest, trading in the Community, should correspond to the rationale of a private vendor operating under normal market economy conditions analogous to the Commission's position on public authorities' holdings in company capital (1). In these conditions, a private vendor would examine the possibility of alternative purchase offers and sell the asset to the person making the highest offer. Where the vendor feels that because of special circumstances such as, say, the size of a site or the importance of planning conditions, alternative potential purchasers are not immediately available and where he has no reliable reference for market values for the asset, he would have the asset professionally valued, taking account of all the prevailing circumstances and non-price conditions of sale, prior to selling it. He would then seek the resulting valuation figure as the sale price from the purchaser.

In the case of the sale of the site at Burnaston, the DCC did not carry out any valuation of the site prior to offering it to Toyota in April 1989. The only valuation available to the DCC related to the core 280 acres of the site was carried out in June 1989, i.e. after the price offer to Toyota. As noted in the opening of the present procedure, this valuation exceeded the price sought from Toyota by £ 2,7 million and no attempt was made by the DCC to revise the sale price to take account of this difference. No valuation of the remainder of the site was carried out by the DCC on its own initiative.