, Decision_act (EU) 1992/11

In forcesince 31 Jul 1991

On the arguments put forward by the United Kingdom Government and Toyota subsequent to the District Valuer's report, the Commission would firstly make the general point that these arguments would have carried more conviction if they had been put forward prior to the United Kingdom authorities' accepting the terms of reference of the valuation requested by the Commission and the submission by the District Valuer of his report. On the particular argument that the valuation should have been based on April 1989 and not February 1990 prices, the District Valuer himself has confirmed that this would not have affected his conclusion. Moreover, the Commission does not find sufficient evidence in the study on land price movements during this period commissioned by the United Kingdom authorities to warrant querying this conclusion. On the argument that costs arising from alleged constraints relating to the gradient of the land and adverse ground conditions, the Commission is of the view that such costs are a common feature of large sites assembled for industrial development, in particular the related piling costs associated with greenfield motor assembly plants. They did not warrant special consideration by the District Valuer over and above the 'particular account of the topography' which his report already incorporates.

On the alternative valuations commissioned by the United Kingdom authorities on their own initiative subsequent to receiving the District Valuer's report and his letter confirming that a February 1990 price basis would make no difference to his conclusion, the Commission cannot agree to embark on a second-guessing exercise whereby one party wishes to substitute ex post a private valuer for an officialy-designated one in the absence of any compelling reason to do so. This would not be in the interests of equity and consistency in Commission decision making. Moreover the Commission does not consider that the contents of this confidential valuation justify the criticisms of the District Valuer's methodology subsequently made by Toyota.