on the difference between the sale price to Toyota of the core 280 acres of £ 9,9 million and its valuation by the District Valuer at £ 12,6 million, several factors should be borne in mind. Land valuation is not an exact science particularly for a unique and exceptionally large site such as this one. The sale price reflected the outcome of a hard-fought commercial negotiation where Toyota was in a particularly strong bargaining position. Moreover, the District Valuer had not been aware of a number of constraints which would burden and add to the costs of developing the land but which the DCC had been aware of. In particular the gradient of the land, which required considerable earthworks to provide a level site, and the adverse ground conditions which would give rise to extensive piling prior to building works, would cost Toyota a total of £ 16 million.
By letter dated 20 December 1990 the Commission requested further information on certain aspects of the land transactions between the DCC and Toyota in advance of a bilateral meeting requested by the United Kingdom authorities. These included the regulatory provisions governing sales of assets by local authorities, evidence of comparable transactions elsewhere in the United Kingdom if available, trends in land prices, and evidence of other potential purchasers of the site at Burnaston.
By letter dated 1 February 1991 the United Kingdom Government replied to the Commission. They provided further background information on the site transfer to indicate that it should be considered as a single whole transaction covering the 580 acres. They also enclosed the relevant legal provision in the Local Government Act 1972 governing the criteria for the disposal of assets. This stipulates that local authorities are generally not allowed to dispose of land 'for a consideration less than the best that can reasonably be obtained'. Little conclusive evidence on comparable land transactions elsewhere in the United Kingdom or another potential purchaser of the site in question was available or forthcoming. The letter did point out that, in general, advice given to a local authority by a District Valuer was neither legally required nor legally binding.