Shortly afterwards the United Kingdom authorities informed the Commission authorities that the District Valuer was agreeable to carrying out the valuation.
By letter dated 17 May 1991 the United Kingdom authorities forwarded the report of the District Valuer to the Commission and requested an early meeting to discuss it.
In his report, the District Valuer describes in detail the site, its former uses, the planning permission granted on 9 August 1989 for the erection of a vehicle assembly and production plant together with the accompanying conditions and the sale agreement which had been made available to him. He then acknowledged the terms of reference for his valuation and described the nature of his valuation in the following terms:
'I wish to make clear therefore that my valuation is my assessment of the price at which the property might reasonably have been expected to be sold in the open market at the date of valuation assuming a willing seller and with the benefit of the terms of the agreement for sale and planning permission available.
For the avoidance of doubt it reflects all the site characteristics and constraints that would have influenced the vendors and purchasers in normal commercial open market negotiations.'
On this basis the District Valuer concluded that the value of the site was £ 22,5 million. He added that extensive research on a national scale had revealed no comparable transactions of this size and little useful evidence.
At a meeting between the United Kingdom Government representatives and the Commission on 28 May 1991, the former argued that the District Valuer's report, while valid within its own terms, still did not establish that there was State aid to the project. There was no evidence of any intention on the part of Toyota to request or receive State aid. On a technical point, the United Kingdom representatives argued that the District Valuer should have been requested to base his valuation on land prices at April 1989 - when the terms of the sale were actually agreed - and not February 1990 - when the sale agreement was formally signed. Finally, even if there were State aid, the amount was so negligible that it would not affect trade between Member States.