, Decision_act (EU) 1992/11

In forcesince 31 Jul 1991

At a meeting with representatives of the United Kingdom Government on 19 March 1991, the Commission stated that, in the light of the evidence and arguments presented in the most recent correspondence, they now accepted that the sale of the 580-acre site by the DCC to Toyota should be viewed as one single transaction. To establish whether this transaction contained elements of State aid, however, it was necessary to have a valuation carried out of this total site and the Commission requested the United Kingdom authorities to arrange accordingly. The Commission suggested, but did not insist, that the District Valuer appeared the obvious choice to carry out this exercise in the interests of consistency and in view of his statutory role. They also indicated the terms of reference they would wish to attach to the valuation. The United Kingdom representatives did not object to the suggestion that the District Valuer carry out the valuation, providing he was willing to do so, or to the proposed terms of reference.

By letter dated 26 March 1991 the Commission wrote to the United Kingdom authorities confirming the request for a valuation of the 580-acres site, with the following terms of reference:

'The valuation should follow the assumptions and methodology adopted in the original valuation of the core element of the site in the absence of any compelling reason to depart from them. Specifically, the valuation should be based on values on the date of sale agreement, i.e. February 1990 and should assume that services are available up to the perimeter of the site and that vacant possession is given. It should ignore alleged disadvantages pertaining to the expansion element of 300 acres - e.g. access and lower development potential. However relevant these may be if this element of the site were being valued in isolation, they are irrelevant when the total 580 acres is considered as one single site being sold with full planning permission for industrial development. Finally I do not consider that the valuation should attempt to take account of the two "significant constraints" relating to the gradient of the land and adverse ground conditions you cite in your letter of 16 October 1990. In our experience these "constraints" are, in fact, a standard feature of large sites assembled for industrial development. The related piling costs are also a standard cost for greenfield motor assembly plants.'