Under the terms of the site sale agreement between the DCC and Toyota of 21 February 1990, Toyota would purchase the first 280 acres of the site from the DCC for £ 9 900 000 (ECU 14,1 million), equivalent to an average sale price per acre of £ 35 357, and will purchase as much of the remaining 300 acres of the same site as it requires for £ 28 000 per acre. Assuming that Toyota decided to purchase all of the remaining 300 acre site, this would bring the sale price of the remaining site to £ 8,4 million (ECU 12 million) and that of the total 580-acre site to £ 18,3 million (ECU 26,1 million).
The first 280 acres of the site had been formally valued by the Derby District Valuer at £ 12,6 million (ECU 18 million), equivalent to £ 45 000 per acre. This valuation assumed it was a vacant freehold site with services available at the site perimeter and was calculated at current market values, discounted to take account of the likely timescale before such infrastructure is completed. The District Valuer acknowledged that considerably smaller sites suitable for industrial development in this area can fetch from £ 200 000 to £ 250 000 per acre, but advised that a large discount factor should be applied to the value per acre of sales of very large sites. Account must also be taken, of course, of the particular characteristics of each individual site.
The Commission accepted the case for discounting sales prices when applying the evidence of small site transactions to very large site transactions, while noting the high discount of some 80 % applied in the present case. It noted, however, that the 280-acre site was sold to Toyota at an average price per acre of only £ 35 357 or 78,6 % of its average value of £ 45 000 according to the District Valuer, despite the legal obligation on the DCC and all local authorities to realize the best value from the sale of assets. The Commission was therefore of the view that £ 45 000 per acre should be the minimum sale price of the first 280 acres. On this basis the sale price of the first 280 acres should have been, as a minimum, £ 12,6 million, or £ 2,7 million more than the price charged to Toyota.