The Toyota representatives emphasized their publicly-stated intention from the outset to proceed with the project at Burnaston without requesting or receiving State aid from central government or local authorities. They outlined their strictly commercial approach to the consideration of alternative sites and their decision to choose the Burnaston site on the understanding that the price offered by the DCC represented its commercial value. They echoed the United Kingdom representatives' view that a range of site values rather than a single value would have been a more reasonable approach to the question of valuation.
By letter dated 11 July 1991 the United Kingdom authorities enclosed a further internal document prepared by Toyota on the transaction. They requested the Commission to take account of the evidence presented therein, particularly that relating to the prices offered to Toyota for alternative sites in the United Kingdom, while respecting the commercial confidentiality of some of the information. This document also repeated and developed some of the general arguments advanced earlier by the United Kingdom side that the transaction did not entail State aid. Among the points made are:
as this could be the first case where the Commission takes a decision on State aid on a sale of public land, it should not be 'based upon only cursory investigation and insubstantial evidence',
any valuation of the site should take account of all the relevant considerations and objectives of the parties, including the fact that Toyota were in a strong bargaining position vis-à-vis the DCC who were offering a large undeveloped site which could prove difficult to sell in the future and who were also conscious of the considerable non-financial benefits to the DCC if the sale went through,
the alternative valuation commissioned by the United Kingdom authorities highlights certain shortcomings in the District Valuer's report, and adds to the case for adopting a price range of, for example £ 16 million to £ 24 million, rather than a fixed sum as the valuation.
IV