The Italian authorities stated that the measures under examination applied only to companies that were almost exclusively involved in providing what they described as local public services, i.e. services on a local scale in the sectors of electricity, gas, water, transport, waste, and pharmaceutical products. The Italian authorities argued that the measures did not constitute State aid for the following reasons:
they did not distort competition because when they were adopted the sectors in which the joint stock companies operate were not open to competition;
they did not affect trade between Member States because the companies operated on a purely local level;
they were not financed from State resources as the State did not forgo resources to which it was entitled. Being part of the public administration, the recipients were already exempt from tax even before they were converted into joint stock companies. Rather, the State earned revenue at the level of the municipalities.