Cispel, an association representing such joint stock companies and special undertakings, commented as follows:
at the time the measures in question in the sector concerned were adopted, there was a legal monopoly. Local authorities could either reserve for themselves the provision of certain services on their territory or grant licences to third parties together with exclusive rights. As there is thus no competition, the measure cannot be regarded as constituting State aid under Article 87(1);
the measures were intended to facilitate the conversion of public-sector undertakings governed by public law into firms governed by common law via a transition from a monopolistic situation to a competitive one. They did not discriminate between private- and public-sector undertakings because the latter were in a different position: they did not require any changes in order to operate in the market. The measures should therefore be regarded at least as compatible aid under Article 87(3)(c), which provides for aid aimed at facilitating the development of certain economic activities;
in addition, the measures do not constitute State aid because: (i) the joint stock companies are not undertakings for the purposes of competition law; (ii) the measures simply offset the extra cost of the public service entrusted to them; (iii) they are not financed from State resources as the State forgoes tax revenues at central level but gains at local level; (iv) they are general measures; (v) they are justified by the nature and general scheme of the system: under Italian tax law, the legislator has a wide margin of manoeuvre in determining taxable persons and was therefore able to exempt the joint stock companies for a transitional period; (vi) they did not affect trade between Member States since the goods and services produced by the recipients are not traded between Member States but intended only for the local market; (vii) the transfer tax exemption does not confer any advantage on the joint stock companies as the municipality would have been liable for the taxes in any case.