Another effect of Articles 4 and 5 is to restrict a carrier's ability to meet market requirements. The provisions on minimum aircraft size compel companies to use aircraft which do not correspond to traffic levels, which calls into question the commercial viability of their operations and limits de facto to four the number of daily services offered.
The restrictions in Articles 4 and 5 of the decree cannot be justified either by environmental considerations or by congestion problems at Orly. First, the need to use aircraft of a certain size tends to increase polluting emissions and noise. Secondly, the restrictions imposed are not proportional to the problems they are supposed to solve since the French authorities, with the very aim of protecting the environment and local residents, have already limited, by decree of 6 October 1994, the maximum number of slots for Orly to 250 000 per year.
In any event, problems associated with the environment and airport congestion can be resolved only by following the procedure laid down by Article 9 of Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92.
Finally, the provisions of Article 7 of the decree cannot be justified on the basis of Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92, in particular Article 8 (1) thereof, in so far as they restrict opportunities for the joint marketing of services by air carriers established in the Member States of the EEA. Referring to Commission Decision 93/347/EEC (1) in the Viva Air case, the UK authorities consider in particular that any air carrier holding an operating licence must, under the first paragraph of Article 8 of the Regulation, be considered a carrier in its own right, there being no need to take account of any links with any other carrier.
III
By letter of 22 December 1994, the Commission informed the French authorities of the United Kingdom's request and asked them to reply to a number of questions and to submit, if they so wished, their observations on any of the abovementioned arguments. On the same day, the Commission further addressed a letter to the UK authorities in order to inquire into a number of factual elements and any information on the actual application of the traffic distribution rules of 15 November 1994.
The UK authorities replied to the Commission's request for additional information by letter of 16 January 1995, which can be summarized as follows: