, Decision_act (EU) 1995/259

In force

Since, however, Articles 4 and 5 of the decree concern only the services to and from the airport of Orly, the annual traffic volume on any given route may only validly be used for determining the minimum aircraft size pursuant to Article 5 if such volume is defined as the total number of passengers travelling between that airport and any other airport located within the EEA. In particular, traffic volume cannot be defined in these circumstances by reference to the airport system of Paris, nor by reference to the airport system of which the other airport may be a part, without incurring the risk that, in practice, the application of Article 5 will result, in some cases, in disproportionate barriers to entry.

This can best be explained by comparing the situations of two different airports which are each served out of both Orly and Charles-de-Gaulle. Whilst the overall traffic volume between each of the former two airports and the airport system of Paris may be identical, the relative importance of the traffic into Orly on the one hand, and into Charles-de-Gaulle on the other may vary significantly. Although the traffic volume of one of the routes to and from Orly may represent only a fraction of the volume of the other route to and from that airport, both routes would fall within the same category of minimum aircraft size established under Article 5 of the decree. Thus, the carrier wishing to operate a new or low-capacity route between Orly and another EEA airport could risk being required to use large capacity aircraft that are inappropriate to the actual traffic on the route, solely for the reason that there is significant traffic between that latter airport and Charles-de-Gaulle.

The information provided by the UK authorities with respect to the route Paris (Orly)-London confirms that the risk is further increased by the fact that, where the airport at the other end of the route is part of an airport system, the traffic volume is defined by reference to that airport system. The application of Article 5 of the decree to that route would in fact result in a disproportionate restriction of additional services out of Gatwick and Stansted and, ultimately, in a redistribution of traffic within the airport system of London. Such traffic distribution cannot, however, be a legitimate objective of the French authorities' airport policy for Paris.