, Decision_act (EU) 1995/259

In force
–

Article 5 of the decree discriminates against carriers operating out of airport systems, since the minimum size of the aircraft is determined not by reference to the annual traffic between the airports actually served, but by reference to the traffic between the respective airport systems to which those airports belong. This amounts to systematically requiring the use of large aircraft where a carrier wishes to operate services between an airport belonging to an airport system and Orly Airport, even if the traffic between those two airports does not in itself justify the use of aircraft of such size. It is a definite constraint from the point of view of the conditions for operating the routes concerned. Such discrimination is all the more apparent as airport systems exist in only four Member States other than France. In particular, it appears that access to the Paris (Orly)-London route may be more restricted than access to any other route because of the different volumes of traffic at the London airports. In this connection, the UK authorities state that in 1993 annual traffic between Charles-de-Gaulle Airport and Heathrow was 2 911 546 passengers, compared with 470 611 to and from Gatwick and 168 837 to and from Stansted. Thus Article 56 indirectly favours services from Heathrow rather than from Gatwick and Stansted, even though the latter have more spare capacity.

–

Still in connection with Article 5 of the decree, the various categories of minimum size of aircraft do not appear to be based on rational and justifiable criteria.

–

Articles 4 and 5 of the decree have negative and discriminatory effects for many Community carriers, particularly those operating only small and medium-sized aircraft. Thus, the UK authorities consider that only one British company, British Airways, is currently capable of operating more than four frequencies between London and Orly Airport, whereas four French companies are in a position to do so. Moreover, the new distributive rules restrict competition by favouring large carriers over smaller ones and potential newcomers. Certain French companies already established on domestic routes, such as Air Inter and AOM, appear to benefit greatly from the new rules, whereas small companies such as Euralair find their development prospects limited.

  • celex=31992R2408