, Decision_act (EU) 1995/259

In force

With regard to discrimination on grounds of the identity of the carrier, none of the information in the possession of the Commission suggests that Article 5 of the decree in question might lead to such discrimination, as specifically defined in its Decision 94/291/EC (TAT - Paris (Orly-Marseilles and Paris (Orly-Toulouse) (2).

Therefore, the Commission takes the view that Article 5 does not violate the prohibition of any discrimination on grounds of nationality or identity of an air carrier.

Next, consideration needs to be given to whether the provisions of Articles 4 and 5 of the decree also comply with the principles governing the freedom to provide services, as explained in section V. In this respect, any restriction of the freedom to provide services must be justified on grounds of overriding considerations of public interest, proportionate to the objectives sought.

In this context, it should first be recalled that those provisions restrict access to Orly in so far as the operation of more than four frequencies per route and per carrier is made subject to the use, during peak hours, of aircraft of a certain minimum size. Thus the provisions do not impose any absolute restriction on either the maximum number of frequencies or the aircraft size to be used. Nonetheless, the provisions are capable of affecting the ability of air carriers to operate an unlimited number of services to and from Orly in accordance with their own commercial preferences, and hence obstruct the freedom of access to the market established by Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92. In view of the size of the airport and its role as the gateway to Paris and the hub of the domestic network (3), that market access barrier must also be considered to be appreciable.