In the case of the company providing scheduled urban public transport (ACTV), the service, including transport in the lagoon, which given the special situation of Venice can be treated in the same way as scheduled urban public transport, was during the period concerned operated under a monopoly established by law, in a non-liberalised sector. The fact that a sector has not been liberalised is not always a sufficient condition for ruling out any impact on trade. However, in the case in point, since the service is provided locally and there is no scope for potential competition as ACTV has been granted an exclusive right to operate it and the instrument granting that right to ACTV allows the firm to engage only in the activities specified therein, there can be no impact on trade. In view of the foregoing, the relief from social security contributions granted to ACTV cannot be regarded as aid since the conditions for the application of Article 87(1) of the Treaty are not met in the case in point, there being no impact on intra-Community trade. In such circumstances it is not necessary to ascertain whether the exemption provided for by Article 86(2) is applicable.
Recital 90, Decision_act (EU) 2000/394
In forcesince 25 Nov 1999