They claimed that the exemption under Article 87(3)(a) and (c) of the Treaty could be applied to these measures for the following reasons:
(a)
the reductions and exemptions contributed to the long-term development of the islands of the Venice region;
(b)
it was a matter of Community interest that the islands of the Venice region benefit from the measures; there was a clear link between safeguarding the economy of Venice and the preservation of the city as a place of universal interest as described by Unesco;
(c)
the measures had no impact on intra-Community trade, as they were a method of offsetting additional burdens faced by Venetian companies and because the Venetian economy served a local market.