When the Commission initiated the procedure under Article 88(2) of the Treaty, it observed that the reduction of social security contributions for existing jobs constituted prima facie operating aid. This type of aid can be authorised, under certain conditions, only in regions eligible for exemption under Article 87(3)(a) of the Treaty. The cities of Chioggia and Venice are not eligible for this exemption, since they do not belong to a NUTS level II region with a per capita GDP lower than 75 % of the Community average(4). As regards the exemption from social security contributions for new jobs created, the Commission observed that, since it was a question of total exemption and since the Italian Government had not provided any further information for its assessment, it was not in a position to conclude that the amount of aid was proportional to the objective pursued. Moreover, while the city of Chioggia is eligible for regional aid under Article 87(3)(c), the city of Venice is only partly eligible for that derogation. It also expressed doubts regarding the compatibility of the measures with the common market in that, in the areas of Venice not eligible for regional aid, the aid does not appear to be consistent with the guidelines on aid to employment, as it does not appear to be limited to small and medium-sized enterprises (SME) nor intended to encourage firms to take on certain groups of workers experiencing particular difficulties entering or re-entering the labour market.
Recital 16, Decision_act (EU) 2000/394
In forcesince 25 Nov 1999