With regard to the permitted level of aid, the German authorities claim that the new Laender now qualify as least developed areas if the latest statistics are taken into account. They refer to the Delors II package, where these areas are proposed as Objective 1 areas, which makes them eligible for regional aid up to 75 % NGE.
Article 92 (3) (b)
Germany argues that this is a further legal basis for the granting of aid in these cases. In its view the problems of integration and restructing of the former planned economy into a market economy represent a serious disturbance of the German economy.
Non-applicability of the Community framework on State aid to the motor vehicle industry between 1 January 1991 and 31 March 1991.
The German authorities insist that the Community framwork was renewed and altered (thereby including West Berlin) in a legally incorrect way so that they were able to consider the Commission's letter of 31 December 1990 (renewal) as a non-binding recommendation based on Article 93 (1). They thus consider that the Community framework was no longer applicable to them as from 1 January 1991. It is accepted that the Community framework was binding once again as from 1 April 1991 given that the Commission's letter of 11 April 1991 on regional aid in the new Laender stipulates compliance with existing frameworks. The Commission had been orally informed of this position in early 1991 and should not therefore, in accordance with Article 5 of the EC Treaty, have objected to such aid by initiating a procedure.
V
The only comment which the Commission received from other Member States following publication of the opening of the Article 93 (2) procedure in the Official Journal of the European Communities was a note from France dated 7 January 1993, in which it pointed out that, in view of the additional car-making capacity created by Volkswagen's investments and other assisted projects in the new Laender, it was keeping a close eye on the Commission's handling of the case. The French Government further stressed that:
the new German Laender should not be exempt from Community solidarity with regard to State aid granted pursuant to Article 92 (2) (c),
the approval of any aid by the Commission should be based on a detailed analysis of the incremental costs attributable to the structural handicaps of the new Laender and of any indirect support provided by THA.