consideration of any possible adverse effects on the sector as a whole arising from the granting of the proposed aid measures, in particular with respect to capacity development.
On 16 June 1993 the Commission approved rescue aid in the form of bank loan guarantees by THA for Saechsische Automobilbau GmbH (SAB or Mosel I) of up to DM 150 million to secure the interim financing of Mosel I until the final decision in the present case (1). This had become necessary as the company was facing a shortage of liquidity after the payment stop for aid, which included the loss coverage by THA.
IV
With regard to the joint venture SAB, the German Government and Volkswagen argued that:
Mosel I had been created by THA and Volkswagen in December 1990 as part of the restructuring of the former VEB Sachsenring, the producer of the Trabant car, which had been taken over by THA in 1990. The joint venture had been the least costly option for restructuring that was acceptable from a social point of view. Mosel I and associated efforts in the restructuring of the old Zwickau plants were also a necessary interim step for the planned new project Mosel II as it served to build up a skilled workforce in the area,
the joint venture had taken over the existing car plant at Mosel, including a paint shop, from VEB Sachsenring with effect from 1 July 1991 at a price determined by independent accountants on the basis of asset replacement values,
Mosel I had originally been assembling Polo cars and was currently producing Golf cars for its own account. Until the end of 1992, all materials were obtained in 'completely knocked-down' form (CKD) from Volkswagen at prices corresponding to the normal prices applied internally within the Volkswagen Group. The assembled cars were subsequently sold back to Volkswagen at a price equalling the final market sales price less sales and distribution costs. This was common practice for all assembly plants within the Volkswagen Group. The costs of inputs received from Volkswagen were also linked to the development of the end-user price by a 'price corridor' to ensure that the value added at Mosel I remained constant even in the event of falling end-user market-prices. Thus, no advantage as compared to assembly in other plants accrued to Volkswagen by this arrangement,