, Decision_act (EU) 1994/1068

In force
–

the Commission wanted to ascertain whether the arrangements between THA and Volkswagen relating to the project, in particular as regards taking over of losses of Mosel I, and the sales prices received by THA for the Mosel I, Chemnitz and Eisenach plants, contained elements of State aid. The information provided up to that time by the German authorities was not sufficient to quantify the State aid element in those arrangements,

–

furthermore, it was necessary to ascertain whether the restructuring aid provided to these plants by the German Government and THA complied with the requirements for this type of aid and in particular whether it was in proportion to the restructuring effort undertaken.

The information obtained from the German authorities and Volkswagen in the course of the procedure has enabled the Commission to acquire a fuller picture of all aid elements and of the amount of such aid.

With regard to the agreement of THA to cover 87,5 % of the accumulated losses of Mosel I between 1991 and 1993, up to a limit of DM 430 million, the Commission considers that this agreement does not correspond to the normal behaviour of a private investor when participating in a joint venture. This follows from the fact that, although THA holds an 87,5 % stake in Mosel I, the company was to be taken over by Volkswagen with effect from 1 January 1993 at a price based on the company's assets or its earnings value. Thus THA was not in a position to recover any of the joint venture's losses incurred and compensated for by it up to that date. In view of the fact that the total accumulated losses of Mosel I up to 1993 amounted to DM 673,5 million (DM 415 million up to the end of 1992), the Commission concludes that the full DM 430 million constitutes State aid. As regards the claim made by Volkswagen and SAB that THA has to pay DM 20,5 million in interest for its arrears in loss compensation payments to SAB, it must be borne in mind that any aid proposal has to be judged in advance by the Commission and that any claim for aid becomes valid only after Commission approval. Consequently, any interest charged because THA cannot pay aid to SAB before the end of the Commission's investigation would constitute further aid.