As regards the acquisition of the Chemnitz plant, the Commission notes that THA took over the old Barkas engine plant, which was technologically outdated and thus did not meet Western European standards in quality and productivity, and undertook a slow restructuring effort combined with a gradual reduction in the workforce. Continuation of production in that period mainly served to maintain employment (Beschaeftigungsgesellschaft), a path that no rational private investor would have followed and which led to losses of DM 59 million. Their compensation by THA, before the new entity, MWC, was set up, is thus a direct consequence of the belated restructuring efforts of THA. Deducting this amount, which can be regarded as State aid only to Barkas, and the sum of DM 83,7 million spent by THA on decontamination, THA's investment in MWC amounts to DM 71,3 million (1991 to 1993), while loss compensation to MWC was DM 18 million (1991). This loss compensation as well as the investment aid of DM 7,8 million have to be regarded as State aid to MWC. THA could reasonably have expected to recover the remaining investment in MWC through the sales price to Volkswagen.
As regards the sale of MWC to Volkswagen at the beginning of 1992, the Commission was concerned that this might result in an unreasonably low price. The actual sales price amounts to DM 68 million. It corresponds to the asset value as determined by an auditing company hired jointly by THA and Volkswagen, which exceeded an independent cash-flow valuation yielding DM 65 million. The Commission informed the German authorities that this asset valuation could not be regarded as an objective valuation because the valuers were instructed to arbitrarily assess the fixed assets at DM 50 million. It was also concerned that the cash-flow valuation might underestimate the value of the plant as it was based on the assumption that the plant would terminate its operations in June 1994 and that all the workers would be made redundant at that time, involving high redundancy costs. As the new plant Chemnitz II will begin to operate only 18 months later, this assumption cannot be maintained. If these alleged redundancy costs are excluded, the cash flow- valuations would match the asset-based valuation.