, Decision_act (EU) 1994/1068

In force
–

the obligation of THA to cover the losses of Mosel I up to DM 430 million did not constitute State aid to Volkswagen. The continuing losses were due to the fact that CKD production was generally uneconomic when compared to 'fully built-up' (FBU) production; the assembly work could be performed more efficiently at other Volkswagen plants. Additional losses were caused by the product changeover to the new Golf A3 in August 1992. Volkswagen was sharing the losses in proportion to its 12,5 % equity participation. Moreover, the loss coverage by THA was limited to DM 430 million, which was less than 65 % of the total accumulated losses of Mosel I by the end of 1993, which amounted to DM 673,5 million,

–

as the Commission, on opening the procedure, had issued a payment stop on all aid payments to Mosel I, THA's payments of loss compensation to SAB which, according to the contract setting up this company, were to occur quarterly, could not be made either. Volkswagen therefore argued that SAB could charge interest on these arrears against THA, which it calculates at DM 20,5 million. This would be common commercial practice and would not constitute aid,

–

the price at which Volkswagen will take over the remaining 87,5 % stake in Mosel I from THA with effect from 1 January 1993 is equal to 87,5 % of the replacement value of net assets, or at least DM 150 million. Consequently, there is no reason to believe that the price would involve an aid element. The actual valuation led to a sales price of DM 180 million, to which a further DM 70 million for the present value of the use of the accumulated loss carryforwards has to be added.

With regard to Motorenwerke Chemnitz GmbH (the former VEB Barkas plant, or Chemnitz I), Germany and Volkswagen argued that:

–

VEB Barkas had established a facility for the production of 1,1 and 1,3 litre four-stroke engines based on Volkswagen technology. After German monetary union, Volkswagen remained the sole customer for these engines. Volkswagen was paying the same prices to Barkas - later renamed Motorenwerke Chemnitz GmbH (MWC) - as the internal prices applied to engines built in Volkswagen's plant in Salzgitter. The losses of Barkas/MWC until the take-over of the plant by the Volkswagen Group in January 1992 were due not to product pricing but to the inefficiency and capacity under-utilization of the old plant. The coverage of these losses by THA did not, therefore, amount to indirect State aid to Volkswagen,