, Decision_act (EU) 1994/1068

In force

On opening the procedure the Commission had regarded all Volkswagen's investment plans in Saxony as a single project and therefore intended to decide on all elements of State aid together. Even after its decision in 1993 to postpone investment in the new plants, Volkswagen initially argued that this did not affect the production technology, the labour input and other crucial variables. This year, however, on the basis of information collected during a site visit and through new expert advice, it became obvious that this view could no longer be maintained. Volkswagen also acknowledged to the Commission that their former plans had become obsolete and that they were being reworked. The new plans for the new car and engine plants Mosel II and Chemnitz II will now be closely linked to the development of the Golf A4 that will be put into production at the same time as Mosel II is now planned to come on stream, i.e. in 1997. A final version of the new plans will only be available at the end of 1994. On the basis of current information these new plans will include significant changes in technology and production structure. Under these circumstances it is obvious that the original link between the investment projects in the existing former THA plants and the new greenfield projects has been severed. The Commission has therefore decided to limit its current decision to the restructuring aid for the existing plants, on which it can form a clear opinion on the basis of the available information, and to postpone the decision on the aid to the greenfield projects until Volkswagen and Germany are able to present their definitive investment and aid plans. This Decision thus covers the proposed aid to the Mosel I, Chemnitz I and Eisenach projects.

As to the compatibility of the proposed State aid measures, Germany argued further as follows:

(i)

Article 92 (2) (c)

This should be the legal basis for the assessment of the compatibility of the aid measures. Despite the fact that Germany was unified on 3 October 1990, the new Laender still suffer from economic disadvantages which result from the division of Germany. The Commission should therefore examine whether such economic disadvantages still justify State aid. If so, all other assessment criteria and in particular those related to the Community framework on State aid to the motor vehicle industry, including sectoral considerations and the possible risk of overcapacity, do not apply.

(ii)

Article 92 (3) (a)