Investment aid amounting to DM 7,8 million in the form of direct investment grants and tax breaks for the investments decided on under THA ownership and executed in 1992 and 1993 has been awarded to support the restructuring process. As the company has returned to profitability, the process can be judged a success. However, the aid can be accepted only if the relevant clause of the sales contract, which stipulates that the aid is to be transferred back to THA, which paid for these investments, is complied with.
The investment undertaken by Volkswagen in Chemnitz I after 1993 and hence after the end of the restructuring plan has to be assessed, however, under the Community framework on innovation, modernization and rationalization. Since the investments constitute normal modernization and replacement investment, according to the Community framework they can in principle not be supported by State aid. Consequently, only those investments in Chemnitz I paid for by Volkswagen Sachsen which are transferred to the new plant Chemnitz II may be eligible for regional aid, and this only to the amount of their book value at the time of transfer.
Consequently, the Commission can accept restructuring aid by THA to Barkas in the form of loss compensation of up to DM 59 million and to MWC in the form of loss compensation and investment aid to the amount of DM 18 Million and DM 7,8 million respectively. This amount of restructuring aid to MWC is considered by the Commission as necessary but also as sufficient for the plant restructuring plan executed by THA and Volkswagen in the period from 1991 to 1993. This restructuring was not accompanied by a reduction in capacity. As explained above, Chemnitz I contributed to the temporary overcapacity of engines in Volkswagen, which required a new split of engine production between the Salzgitter and Chemnitz plants, as a result of which both plants worked below capacity. In this case the Commission considers it technically impossible to demand a compensating reduction of capacity, as Chemnitz I had only one production line. Demanding the closure of Chemnitz I would also have run counter to the regional development objective pursued by the plant, as explained above. Finally, the Commission's concern has always been about car production capacity, which is not affected by this plant.