Furthermore, on the assumption that the old plant would stop production of EA 111 engines in June 1994, the Commission was originally satisfied that the price corresponded to a fair value of the plant and did not contain any element of State aid to Volkswagen. In the light of new information provided by Volkswagen and the German Government to the effect that production of the EA 111 1,05 l engine will continue in a slightly modified form at the plant at least until 1996 and that the engine dress-up and testing lines, the use of which was not originally planned by Volkswagen, have been employed since 1993 and will continue to be employed to produce the 1,3/1,6 l engines mainly destined for Mosel I, the Commission questioned whether the earnings valuation of MWC was not based on incomplete information and thus the price would be below a fair market value. It would thus lead to the granting of restructuring aid to the purchaser Volkswagen which would be unjustified, since the company had already been restructured by THA. Volkswagen's claim that this 1,05 l engine, which is to be produced until 1996, is practically a new engine must be rejected in the light of the engine's specifications as presented to the Commission and its automotive expert. These show clearly that the engine is essentially the same as the old version. The very small amount of the investment linked to the changeover (DM 2,7 million) also bears this out. On the basis of the figures in the cash-flow valuation, it was calculated that the average gross contribution to earnings from the continuation of engine production is DM 1 million per month. This calculation was accepted by the German authorities, Volkswagen and THA (1). This amount can, however, be reduced by the normal monthly depreciation of the investment necessary to continue production of the 1,05 l engine in order to obtain the net contribution (according to the information transmitted to the Commission this investment is equal to the abovementioned DM 2,7 million). Unless Volkswagen augments the sales price by the equivalent of this net contribution, the sales price of Chemnitz I would contain State aid.
, Decision_act (EU) 1994/1068
In force