With regard to the old engine plant Chemnitz I, the Commission acknowledges that that plant was technologically outdated and thus did not meet Western European standards of quality and productivity, and that even after substantial investment it could be used for only a limited time. In order to safeguard engine production at the traditional location, THA thus undertook to restructure the plant as an interim solution until the planned future engine plant came on stream. It was clear from the outset that this restructuring would entail substantial investment and involve operating losses during an initial period which no private investor would be willing to absorb. The Commission therefore views the direct investment and the loss compensation by THA in 1991 as part of a single effort to secure the long-term viability of engine production at Chemnitz and consequently concludes that they must be considered as restructuring aid.
Furthermore, as the company was producing short engines (Rumpfmotoren) based on Volkswagen technology, it could be of interest only to Volkswagen. Because of the quality and productivity problems mentioned above, Volkswagen was, however, willing to buy MWC only if THA could ensure its adaptation to Western European standards. Furthermore, as confirmed by the independent valuers, Volkswagen possessed sufficient engine capacity in its Salzgitter plant, so that Chemnitz I was not needed by the company.
The rationale behind the interim project was the need to maintain and train a workforce for engine production at the location until the new plant Chemnitz II was to come on stream. The plant has created or saved 540 jobs in an area suffering from low productivity and high unemployment. In view both of the difficult social consequences that closure of the plant would entail for the regioin and of the aim of socio-economic cohesion, the Commission agrees with the German Government that keeping Chemnitz I in business is in the best interest of the Community.