where global loans are concerned (Articles 54(2) and 56(2) of the ECSC Treaty), the sub-loans relate to capital projects but subsidies are granted as an incentive towards the achievement of objectives resulting from projects, i.e. increased coal consumption, job creation. The subsidy, nevertheless, is paid during the realization period of the project (i.e. before any results can be expected) on the basis that the benefits of the subsidy are most needed at that stage. However, when projects do not produce the anticipated results in terms of the scheme objectives, problems may arise in recovering subsidies already paid;
the interest subsidy payable is based on periodic reports from sponsors of projects or, in the case of global loans, financial intermediaries. The Court established in the course of this study that little effective monitoring of information in these reports was carried out by the financial institutions. Details of coal consumed and jobs created provided by recipients of sub-loans were, with few exceptions, transmitted without verification to the Commission. The Court has previously criticized the Commission's failure properly to define the criteria governing entitlement to interest subsidy and both the Court and the Commission have discovered, as a result of their own monitoring missions, cases where figures in periodic reports were difficult, if not impossible, to verify. The lack of effective monitoring by the financial institutions raises considerable doubts both as to the reliability of achievement, statistics, and the justification for the interest subsidy payments.
Relationship with clients
3.4. When an organization such as the Commission provides a service such as loans and interest subsidies, a measure of the quality of that service can usefully be obtained from the beneficiaries. The Court accordingly decided to pursue this aspect in the course of missions arranged, principally, to test financial intermediaries' control of Commission funds (see paragraph 3.3 (b)). Since only a limited number of institutions could be visited, it was decided to obtain a more representative sample by seeking the written views of the major recipients of both global and direct loans in as many Member States as possible.