2.14. At 31 December 1989 therefore the Communities had a variety of loans and borrowings instruments at their disposal for contributing to the achievement of their economic and social objectives. These range from the strictly sectoral (ECSC, Euratom), to the more flexible NCI and EIB mechanisms, to the particular economic context of BP loans. The utilization of these measures is demonstrated in Table 4 which records the annual level of activity for each instrument from 1975 (when the first of the new measures was introduced) to 1989.
Observations on the management of the instruments
Introduction
3.1. The Commission is as mentioned responsible for contracting borrowings in response to the demand for loans for all three EEC loan instruments. It is directly responsible for the management of ECSC loans and has overall responsibility for NCI and Euratom loans, even if day-to-day management is performed by the EIB.
3.2. In order to test the quality of the Commission's management, the Court adopted an approach which consisted of:
the evaluation and testing of the various systems established by the Commission to discharge its responsibilities;
visits to and circularization of selected clients in order to obtain an impression of the Commission's relationships with its customers.
Systems assessment
3.3. The systems for the control of borrowings, loans and interest subsidies granted on the latter were identified, assessed and tested. The borrowings system is common to all three instruments and, since loans can be made only from borrowings, it was decided to base the tests on a random sample of borrowings between 1985 and 1988 for each instrument, weighted to take account of relative volumes. A sub-sample of the associated loans was taken in order to test controls on lending and, where applicable, interest subsidies. The results of these tests are as follows: