, Special report No 3/90 on ECSC, Euratom and NCI loans and borrowings of the Communities…

In forcesince 10 May 1990

4.7. In addition to the above charges (and over-charges), borrowers under each instrument bear a margin designed to cover the associated administrative costs of the ECSC or the EIB (NCI and Euratom). It is also noted in this connection that most ECSC and NCI loans are global loans to financial intermediaries and that final beneficiaries (normally small and medium-sized enterprises) have to meet, in addition, the margin imposed by the intermediaries. Over the period 1985 to 1988 covered by the study, the Court noted that the ECSC margin was significantly higher than the EIB's margin on new loans. This margin, which, as the Court points out in its Annual Report concerning the financial year 1988, is fixed by the Commission, and in the Court's view seems unreasonably high both in relation to the EIB's rate and to the costs which it was intended to cover. However, between November 1988 and March 1989, this margin was reduced three times and now stands at a level comparable with that of the EIB. The Court has not, as yet, been able to check its effect. But it is possible that the necessary action has been taken to correct a significant source of over-charging in the ECSC cases examined by the Court. The Court is unable to comment on the reasonableness of the EIB's margin since the EIB has refused to provide supporting evidence, despite successive requests.