4.18. As regards other ECSC loans, the Court has recently, in its reports (Annexes to the ECSC Annual Reports 1986 and 1987) on the accounting and financial management of the European Coal and Steel Community, criticized the effectiveness of the Coal Consumption and the Workers' Housing Schemes. Statistics established at the end of 1987 on job creation under the Reconversion Scheme (Article 56(2)) suggest that while the scheme had contributed to the creation of substantially more jobs than estimated (59 000 compared with 29 000) the number filled by ex-ECSC workers was very small (4 000). The accuracy of these figures is, of course, qualified by the comments in paragraph 3.3 (c)(ii). It should also be recognized that the ECSC scheme was, in many Member States, implemented in conjunction with national initiatives of this nature and mainly in association with commercial banks.
4.19. Many projects examined by the Court in recent years had started before the decision on the ECSC loans and/or interest subsidy had been taken. The question arises as to whether these projects could not also have been carried out without this kind of support. While subsidy was appreciated by financial intermediaries, the reason was mainly because of its impact on a package of finance including the intermediaries' own resources. Indeed, one intermediary with substantial funds of its own indicated that the subsidy was required in order to match its competitors' terms. More than one intermediary stated that the decision to grant a subsidy would have no material affect in their assessment of commercial risk. If projects needed the subsidy to be viable, they would not be supported by the intermediaries.
Euratom