4.13 The Commission will study carefully the results of the pilot project currently being carried out in Portugal. However, at this stage of the experiment, it can see certain disadvantages, in particular as regards the uncertain level of lending rates and the difficulty in monitoring the actual progress of the operation. It is also difficult to assess the economic and social impact of financing programmes, the importance of which is underlined by the Court.
4.14. It should be stressed that the 'social clause` as applied at present derives directly from the ECSC Treaty. However, as part of the implementation of the reform of the Structural Funds, the Commission has begun to simplify the rules and procedures for granting ECSC conversion loans. In this context, taking note of the Court's suggestion, the Commission will examine the possibility of establishing a more flexible link between the granting of interest subsidies and the creation of jobs.
Summary
4.15 In its reply to paragraph 4.4, the Commission confirmed that its loans are generally attractive. It will examine ways of improving the administration of interest subsidies in connection with the launching of multiannual schemes.
As regards the pilot project in Portugal, the Commission has already stated the disadvantages it sees in this project in its reply to paragraph 4.13 and feels that at this stage it is premature to suggest extending this kind of initiative to provide financial cover for all the needs of the ECSC priority areas.
Effectiveness
ECSC
4.17 There can be no doubt that in times of crisis or recession, budgetary intervention, especially at national level, and direct measures to assist the workforce tend to come ahead of ECSC loan instruments as a means of financing. However, this does not affect the intrinsic effectiveness of these instruments as might be inferred if reference is made solely to the volume of loans.
The Commission takes the view that the use of the loan instrument under Article 54 has the potential to respond to all situations (expansion, crisis or normal level of investment). It feels that loans will be used more and more to finance conversion initiatives supported by the Community in the context of the new legislation on the Structural Funds and instruments.