, Special report No 3/90 on ECSC, Euratom and NCI loans and borrowings of the Communities…

In forcesince 10 May 1990

4.8 It is difficult to pass on the benefits of re-financing to the varous recipients of loans from the proceeds of a single borrowing by the NCI Treasury. Not only are loans more numerous than borrowings and for different durations, but each loan is normally made up of several currencies, whereas a borrowing is made in a single currency. Moreover, the interest rates for NCI loans are linked to those applied by the EIB to similar operations where the same difficulties in passing on the benefits of re-financing are encountered.

In the Commission's view, re-fnancing operations are consistent with sound financial management and are launched whenever justified by market conditions.

The Commission would stress that it has always passed on the benefits of re-financing:

–

direct to beneficiaries of loans forming part of ECSC, Euratom and NCI back-to-back operations;

–

to the EIB in the case of operations involving the NCI Treasury. Full responsibility for the final result of these operations is assumed by the Bank in accordance with the cooperation convention between the Bank and the Commission.

Summary

4.9 As has already been indicated in the reply to paragraph 4.7, the margin currently applied to ECSC loans reflects the real costs borne by the Commission.

The success of global NCI loans is eloquent proof of the consistent demand for this type of financing even without additional benefits.

As stated in its reply to paragraph 4.8 it has always been the Commission's policy to pass on the benefits of re-financing.

Efficiency

4.12 As it has indicated in its reply to paragraph 4.4, the Commission is well aware of the attraction of interest subsidies but insists on the fact that the success of loans granted without subsidies confirms the general attraction of all its loans.

For the Commission, the important thing is that the rates obtained should be competitive. It would stress that only in rare cases have borrowed funds returned to the lenders and that only modest amounts were involved. These cases were justified by the fact that, in general, the lending institutions had offered the best conditions.

In any event, it cannot be concluded from this that funds return to the lending institutions and that they enjoy the benefit of the interest subsidies, since these subsidies are designed to benefit final beneficiaries and not intermediary banks.