, Special report No 3/90 on ECSC, Euratom and NCI loans and borrowings of the Communities…

In forcesince 10 May 1990

4.11. By far the largest part of the Commission's current lending activity, both under ECSC and NCI, is in the form of global loans. The attraction to recipients of ECSC loans, is that they can benefit from interest subsidies under Article 54(2) or 56(2) of the Treaty. The Court has been unable to establish the attraction of NCI loans since it did not, at the time of the audit, have access to the final beneficiaries. But, from the EIB's point of view, NCI loans provide a facility for clients in non-assisted areas in Member States, the EIB's own loans being directed mainly at the assisted areas.

4.12. The Commission's clients stressed the significance of interest subsidies. In some Member States, exchange risk cover was equally important and some clients whose Governments provided this facility maintained that there would be a continuing demand, even without interest subsidy. But, it is at least arguable that the volume of demand in some Member States would decline, if not cease, if the interest subsidies were abolished. The attraction of a subsidy is demonstrated in some Member States where institutions from which the Commission borrows will themselves borrow from the Commission, in order to obtain a subsidy. Indeed, in some cases, borrowed funds are simply returned to the lender with the benefit of the interest subsidy. In the Courts view the incidence of administrative costs associated with borrowing and lending in such cases is uneconomic. The Court does not ignore that the actual dispositions of the ECSC Treaty does not foresee the allocation of interest subsidies without corresponding ECSC loans. The Court invites the Commission to examine this situation.