, Special report No 3/90 on ECSC, Euratom and NCI loans and borrowings of the Communities…

In forcesince 10 May 1990

4.20. The effectiveness of Euratom loans is difficult to assess. Given the scale of Euratom projects and the political, economic and environmental arguments associated with them, it could hardly be argued that the Euratom contribution (up to 20 % of project costs) was of major significance in the decision to proceed. But, in terms of the objectives of the original legislation, these loans could be regarded as effective if they provided the necessary funds cheaper than other sources of finance. It is not possible to provide a conclusive answer to this question, but the level of demand over the years indicates that the Commission was at least competitive with the market. It could be argued, therefore, that this scheme has contributed, in a small way, to achieving the aims of the energy policy in force at the time of its introduction. Its current effectiveness is reflected in the low level of loans in recent years.

NCI

4.21. To the best of the Court's knowledge, no attempt has been made to assess the effectiveness of NCI loans. For example, one of the prime objectives of the NCI is to create employment yet the Commission statistics refer only to jobs estimated to be created rather than jobs actually created, even after the scheme has operated for some 10 years. The Court also noted that the degree of NCI penetration was uneven amongst Member States. Four Member States do not take NCI funds and the instrument has, accordingly, had no effect in these areas. Two more had not participated in NCI IV, the latest instrument, up to 31 December 1988, and of those which had, one had received more than 60 % of issues at that date. This uneven distribution indicates that NCI loans, which are issued on the same terms as EIB loans, enjoy no special advantage in the market place and that their attraction may owe more to the economic policies of particular Member States (as regards, for example, exchange risk cover) than to the intrinsic merits of the instrument.

Summary