, Special report No 3/90 on ECSC, Euratom and NCI loans and borrowings of the Communities…

In forcesince 10 May 1990

4.8. In recent years, increased emphasis has been given to re-financing - in 1988, 53 % of funds borrowed were for this purpose and in 1989, 36 %. This operation involves the premature redemption of existing borrowings in order to take advantage of better market conditions through replacement borrowings. Since, in the Commission's case, all existing borrowings have been allocated as loans and since the basic objective is to provide funds on the best terms available, the Court examined the extent to which the benefits of re-financing had been passed on to recipients of the original loans. These benefits can be substantial, even without taking account of the potential benefits indicated in paragraphs 4.5 and 4.6. The Court's sample revealed improvements in interest rates on borrowings ranging from 0,50 - 7,17 percentage points, with an average benefit of about 3,15 percentage points. After deduction of related costs, the interest rate charged on loans associated with re-financed borrowings was reduced by 2,5 % on average. The Court observed, however, that no reduction was passed on in the case of loans made from the NCI Treasury. The benefits of re-financing the borrowings associated with such loans remained in the Treasury and accrued, ultimately, to the EIB.

Summary

4.9. The above evidence indicates that the Commission's preferential place in the borrowing market does not always benefit the final beneficiaries because the advantage can be diminished by the Commission's additional costs when fixing the terms of loans, either original or after re-financing. Furthermore, the Court noted that the substantial benefits of re-financing are not passed on to the recipients of NCI global loans. The Court is of the opinion that the Commission must ensure that funds are made available on the best possible market terms.

>TABLE>

Efficiency

4.10. This part of the report tries to establish whether there is a continuing need for lending facilities offered by the Commission, what form that need takes and whether the need is met in the most efficient way.