the change in the character of the Commission's and the EIB's NCI clients, from predominantly industrial or quasi-governmental organizations receiving direct loans to, in the main, banking institutions acting as financial intermediaries for global loans;
the growth in the re-financing activity to take advantage of the markets evolution;
a relative stagnation in the volume of loans;
the banking nature of some transactions, e.g. re-financing of NCI borrowings without passing on the benefits to final beneficiaries;
the raising in particular cases of borrowings in the absence of a demand for loans, although the statutory authority for borrowings for all instruments is dependent on the demand for loans;
the low priority given to measurement of achievement in terms of the objectives of the instruments.
Recommendations
7.1. In the Court's opinion, the loans and borrowings instruments of the Communities should remain, a means to further the objectives of the Communities. However, working practices could be better organized. Collaboration with the EIB is required in order to avoid the risk of duplication of effort. The Court considers that action is required to improve the economy and efficiency of the service and to measure its success in achieving the objectives of the various instruments.
7.2. The Court accordingly recommends:
that the Commission should comply to the basic principle, that borrowings cannot be made without a demand for loans and that the benefits of refinancing operations should be passed on to final beneficiaries;
that the Commission examines the possibilities to improve the impact of the ECSC operations by extending the experience of the pilot project in Portugal to other Member States. Such a development would also identify the Member States which required only interest subsidies and thus streamline the borrowing and lending activity;
in association with (b) above, the administration of interest subsidies should be simplified. Consideration should be given, inter alia, to:
relating entitlement to a subsidy to realization of and continued existence of projects in priority areas on the assumption that job creation will follow automatically;
pre-funding subsidies, in appropriate cases, to enable intermediaries to charge a net interest rate on their loans;
integrating the subsidies with national or other Community initiatives, where possible;